Want to take your chicken dinner game to a whole new level of tender, succulent, and delicious?! The secret is in the marinade! I have the best chicken marinade recipe for you today. Made of whole milk yogurt, citrus, extra virgin olive oil, and loads of Mediterranean flavors from garlic, fresh herbs, and spices. This yogurt chicken marinade is easy to make and super versatile.
Chicken is a convenient, budget-friendly ingredient for many of us.
Every home cook has a couple go-to chicken recipes in her arsenal. But one can easily fall into a rut, making the same chicken dinner over and over.
And when it comes to chicken breasts, for example, many run into issues–not enough flavor, or way too dry (Confession: dry chicken breast is my biggest enemy because it can totally taste and feel like pressed sawdust!)
Time to foolproof the chicken dinner and take it to a whole new level of delicious…
The key to succulent, extra tender, flavor-packed chicken is in the marinade! And as far as good chicken marinades go, one secret ingredient makes a big difference: creamy whole milk yogurt.
You’ll love how versatile this chicken marinade is. It’s great for boneless chicken breasts (that’s what I used in today’s recipe and the video below). But you can use it on any cut of chicken you like.
For quick weeknight dinners–chicken gyros, for example–I often cook my yogurt-marinated chicken in a pan. But if you feel like grilling, or even baking, that will work too.
Why use Yogurt in Chicken Marinade?
With both meat and chicken (especially with chicken breasts), the job of a marinade is to tenderize, while adding flavor.
And, if you’ve been intimated or not sure where to start with marinades, yogurt is the answer.
Creamy, tangy yogurt acts as a great flavor carrier to all sort of herbs and seasonings, including Chicken Gyros. More importantly, because of its lactic acid and calcium content, yogurt works very gently to break down proteins so that the meat is super tender and juicy.
So, with a yogurt marinade, as opposed to a highly acidic or vinegar-based marinade, you don’t have to worry about chicken breasts getting tough or turning rubbery!
What’s in the BEST Chicken Marinade Recipe?
Let’s talk marinade magic! My chicken marinade has it all, plus it’s as easy as 1, 2, 3. Here’s what’s in it:
1. Marinade base: quality whole milk yogurt. I use 1 ½ cups of Stonyfield organic whole milk yogurt (link) from pasture-raised cows. This delicious creamy yogurt is a go-to for me. I love it in marinades, sauces, and I also use it in making my famous Labneh cheese (basically, the best homemade cream cheese!)
2. Citrus and Extra Virgin Olive Oil. These two support the yogurt in building the marinade base. For the citrus, I like to add juice of 2 citrus fruits (lemon or lime will work) and zest of 1 citrus fruit for extra punch.
3. Flavor Makers: Garlic, Spices, and Fresh Herbs. This is a bit of a Greek chicken marinade. As you can expect, loads of fresh garlic (the start of every good thing, in my opinion). Then we have oregano, dried mint and a foursome of warm spices: cumin, coriander, paprika, and nutmeg (just a pinch.) Finally, a generous portion of fresh parsley.
Make this marinade your own!
You can change up the combination of herbs and spices to your liking.
Start with the yogurt marinade base: whole milk yogurt, citrus, and extra virgin olive oil. From there, whisk in the combination of spices and fresh herbs you like
For example, if you have fresh basil or mint, use them instead of parsley. Remember, the finer you chop the fresh herbs, the more flavor they will impart to the marinade.
Want to give your chicken an Italian twist, try some fresh thyme and maybe a little rosemary. Going for a Moroccan vibe? Try a bit of Harissa or Ras El Hanout?
A lot of my Southern friends love heat. If that’s you, feel free to adapt the yogurt marinade recipe by adding cayenne or Cajun spice instead.
You get the idea. Don’t fall into a rut. Change things up whenever you need to!
How Long Can You Marinate Chicken?
The beauty of this chicken marinade is that it’s yogurt-based, which means it will work to tenderize the chicken in about 15 to 30 minutes. But, it’s safe to marinate your chicken in it for a few hours or overnight, which I highly recommend if you’re after big flavor.
What to Serve Along Yogurt Marinated Chicken?
There are lots of Mediterranean sides and salads that will work perfectly with yogurt marinated chicken! A few ideas:
Sides: pan fried brussels sprouts, baked zucchini sticks, Italian roasted veggies, and Greek lemon rice
Salads: Greek Salad, Balela Salad, 3-Ingredient Mediterranean Salad, or Tabouli
Dips: Toum Garlic Sauce, Classic Hummus, or Tztaziki (if you feel like more yogurt)
Watch the Video for How to Make this Chicken Marinade:
More Easy Chicken Recipes to Try:
Best Homemade Chicken Shawarma
You may also enjoy 50+ Top Mediterranean diet recipes. For all recipes, visit us here. JOIN MY FREE E-MAIL LIST HERE.
Print
BEST Chicken Marinade Recipe (W/ Video)
- Total Time: 20 minutes
- Yield: Serves 6
Description
Ready to take your chicken dinner to a whole new level of delicious? The secret to tender, succulent, flavor packed chicken is in this yogurt chicken marinade. Made with whole milk yogurt, citrus, and extra virgin olive oil, with loads of Mediterranean flavors from garlic, spices, and fresh herbs.
Ingredients
For Marinade
- 1 ½ cup Stonyfield Organic Whole Milk Yogurt
- Juice of 2 lemons
- Zest of 1 lemon
- ¼ cup Extra virgin olive oil (I used Private Reserve Greek olive oil)
- 10 to 12 garlic cloves, minced
- 2 tsp Dry Oregano
- 2 tsp Dry mint
- 1 tsp Cumin
- 1 tsp Coriander
- 1 tsp Paprika
- ½ tsp Nutmeg
- Kosher salt and black pepper
- Large handful fresh parsley, chopped
For Chicken
- 1 1/2 lb boneless chicken breast cutlets (see notes)
Instructions
- Prepare the yogurt marinade. Place yogurt, lemon juice, lemon zest and extra virgin olive oil in a mixing bowl or large measuring cup like this one. Add garlic, dried oregano and mint, cumin, coriander, paprika, and nutmeg. Season with kosher salt and black pepper to taste (a large pinch to your liking). Finally, add in fresh chopped parsley.
- Give everything a good whisk or mix until the marinade is well combined.
- Marinate the chicken. Place chicken pieces in large (gallon size) zip-top bag. Pour the marinade on top. Zip the bag shut. Massage the bag so that the chicken is well-coated with the marinade. Place the bag on a baking sheet so that the chicken sits flat in a single layer in the bag. Refrigerate for 2 hours or overnight (if you don’t have the time, even 30 minutes will make a difference.)
- When ready, remove chicken from the bag, and before you cook it, give it just a bit of a shake to remove excess marinade. You have several options for cooking. In this recipe, I pan-seared the chicken (but you can grill or bake as well.)
- Pan-cooked chicken cutlets: Heat 2 to 3 tbsp extra virgin olive oil in a non-stick skillet over medium-high until shimmering but not smoking. Add chicken tenders to the pan (make sure to shake off any excess marinade before adding chicken to the pan.) Cook on one side undisturbed for 5 minutes until browned. Using a pair of tongs, turn chicken over and cook on other side for another 5 minutes or until chicken is done.
- For grilled chicken breast cutlets: Heat an outdoor grill to medium-high and be sure to oil the grates very well. Grill chicken for 5 minutes on one side, then turn over and cook another 3 to 5 minutes or until chicken is fully done (internal temperature should register 165 degrees F.)
- For baked chicken breast cutlets: Heat oven to 400 degrees F. Brush a baking dish with some extra virgin olive oil (make sure there is enough oil so the chicken does not stick.) Arrange chicken in one single layer (do not crowd.) Cover the baking dish tightly with foil and bake for 10 minutes covered, then uncover and bake another 8 to 10 minutes or so. Watch carefully. This can take less or more time depending on the thickness of your chicken breast cutlets. Remove from heat. Let chicken breasts rest (cover with foil or another pan) for 5 minutes or so.
Notes
- Watch the video just above this recipe to see how I make my yogurt marinated chicken
- Cook’s Tip #1: This marinade will work for 1 1/2 to 2 lb chicken pieces of your choice, I used chicken breast here, but bone-in chicken will work as well. Cooking instructions above are meant for chicken breast cutlets, however.
- Cook’s Tip #2: if you have the time, do allow chicken to marinate in the fridge for a few hours or overnight. The lactic acid and calcium in the yogurt will gently break down protein in the meat to help tenderize it, while the minced garlic, spices and fresh herbs work to infuse the chicken with so much flavor.
- Prepare-Ahead Instructions: You can make the actual yogurt marinade 2 nights in advance. Keep the marinade refrigerated, preferably, in a tight-lid glass container until ready to use. You can use it to marinade chicken for a few hours or overnight.
- Nutrition information is based on yogurt marinate only. It will change depending on what cut of chicken you add. If you add 1 1/2 lb boneless, skinless chicken, it will be 257 calories per serving (6 servings)
- Visit our Online Shop for our olive oils and all natural and organic spice collections.
- Prep Time: 10 mins
- Cook Time: 10 mins
- Category: Entree
- Method: Mixed
- Cuisine: Mediterranean
Not sure what happen to my first comment? I pushed submit but doesn’t show a posting at all? If it has to be approved first I apologize for duplicate comment so please delete one. Couldn’t go with out commenting over this recipe but this was insanely good! In the process of trying more recipes from this cook and may possibly buy her cookbook if I like at least a handful of dishes. Glad I was able to find your website. 🙂
Thank you so much for the great review, Sandy! Welcome to The Mediterranean Dish!
Can you freeze the chicken in this marinade?
Hi, Erin. Since there’s dairy in this marinade, it’s not one we’d recommend freezing.
Go to recipe for grilled thighs. Perfect every time!! Thanks!
Whenever I find a recipe online I’m never sure if it’ll be as good as people rank it, but this was TRULY AMAZING! 🤩 The combo of ingredients is delicious. I oven baked my chicken with all the marinade and covered with foil. We stored the leftovers in the marinade too and never threw it out and we thought it was perfect! Definitely try this recipe!
Hi, Aly! Thanks for taking the time to tell us how much you loved the recipe. It means the world to us! Glad to know you found a keeper.
Do you happen to know what the correct Protein calculation for this recipe is? It seems incorrect that chicken and marinade only have 1.3g protein per serving.
thanks
Hi Cathy, Devin here from the Mediterranean Dish team. The main source of protein in this recipe is from the whole milk yogurt, as the calculation doesn’t include the chicken itself. There’s about 375 grams-worth of yogurt in the whole marinade. According to the USDA, 100 grams of whole milk yogurt has 3.82 grams of protein (generally speaking). So that’s about 14.32 grams in the whole marinade, but if you’d like you can use Greek yogurt, which has more than double the amount of protein per gram. Keep in mind a lot of the nutrition won’t actually end up in the dish, since it’s more to flavor the chicken and you shake it off/discard it before cooking. You may want to go based off the chicken itself, with chicken breasts having about 22.5 grams of protein per 100 grams (about 1/4 pound). Hope this helps & happy cooking! 🙂
Made this tonight, everyone raved over the chicken!!! Delicious!!
Hello there, love this marinade. I wanted to marinate over night but didn’t know if I could because of the lemon?
Thank you!
Hi, Robin. That is always a tricky question because, as you probably already know, lemon can affect the texture of the chicken if left to sit too long. I have personally let this one marinade about 8 hours overnight and it was fine. However, if you are worried, you can always just add the lemon to the marinade for the last hour or so.
Thank you for getting back to me, that’s an excellent idea! Love this marinade!!!!!
Can I grill chicken breast in advance and reheat ?
If I can, what is the best way to reheat the chicken before serving ?
Thank you!!
Hi, Marina. grilled chicken breast is best eaten freshly cooked, because it has a tendency to dry out a bit during the reheating process. If you want to give reheating a try, though, I recommend wrapping the chicken in foil with a little water, placing it in an oven at 325°F and heating until the internal temp gets back to 165°F.
Looks delicious! Would this recipe be suitable for skin-on, bone-in chicken thighs?
Absolutely! Enjoy!
This has become my kids’ absolute favorite chicken recipe. They love it on the grill. Made it for kids party recently and they were practically inhaling it. I also love the flexibility of the recipe – you can modify the spices & when I’ve resorted to pan frying on the stove it’s still a hit. It’s now permanent part of our family menu & bbq favorites. Thanks, Suzy!
This was CRAZY good!! Thanks for all of the great recipes!
I made this recipe and followed the directions to the T. All worked out fine, but I opted to bake my chicken in the oven. I greased the pan as instructed, placed my chicken, covered my pan with tin foil and placed it in my 400 degree oven for 10 minutes, removed the tin foil and baked another 10 minutes. The problem was, after a total of 10 minutes, the chicken was floating in water, presumably from the yogurt since the chicken wasn’t frozen and would not brown. I finally had to pull out my indoor grill and use it to get the chicken to brown. The dish did turn out very tender and tasty, so thank you for the recipe, but next time I’ll choose another method of cooking. Thanks again.
I just made this for meal prep to add to salads for my lunches this week. While it was baking, both my teen sons came in at different times and said it smelled good and asked to try it! I guess I have to share now 😂
Oh, no!! Haha! You’ll have to make a double batch next time!!
Could you air fry this recipe? The same way you air fry other non yogurt chicken marinades? Thanks
Hello! Unfortunately, I don’t have an air fryer, so I can’t say. If you give it a try, I’d love to hear your thoughts!
Hi Suzy! I’ve been following you for a year now and your recipes never disappoint! I look forward to your Sunday meal plan for the week, too. Thank you! A question regarding this chicken marinade recipe: I only have fresh mint. How much fresh converts to 2 tsp dry? Thank you!!
Hi, Gwen! Thank you so much for the kind words! Glad you find the meal plan helpful! Regarding the mint… I would go with 2 Tablespoons chopped fresh mint here. Hope that helps!
Hi Suzy,
Can I substitute a dairy free yogurt in this recipe since I’m lactose intolerant?
Hi, Cindy! I don’t have a good recommendation for a non-dairy substitute for the yogurt here, as it is the calcium and lactic acid that make the difference in this marinade. If dairy is an issue, you might try something more like the marinade in this recipe instead: https://www.themediterraneandish.com/mediterranean-grilled-chicken-dill-greek-yogurt-sauce/.
I have a dairy allergy and have found sheep milk yogurt as good as if not better than most store bought yogurt. Bellwether Farms makes an excellent product and dairy (cows milk) free.
Hello😊 This recipe sounds amazing, I can’t wait to try it with greek salad and your smashed feta roasted potatoes at the weekend! I’m just wondering to use chicken thighs, would you use boneless skinless thigh fillets or bone in skin on thighs?
Thank you in advance!
Hi, Victoria! Either will work just fine hear. I would just use whichever you prefer (or happen to have on hand).
Hi Suzy: I’ve been following you for several weeks now and have tried several of the recipes. All of them have been really good, and a nice change from old ones. I was definitely getting in a rut!
My main question is, will you be putting all your wonderful recipes into a cookbook we can order? I’d order several. One for me and others for gifts. I’m trying to eat more healthy style meals and your recipes are great. Keep up the good work! I’ve ordered the Exotic Spice Bundle and a make your own three bundle of your spices. Can’t wait for them to get here!
Thanks for the cooking inspiration!
Hi, Barbara! You are so sweet! Thank you for supporting The Mediterranean Dish! Publishing a cookbook is my dream! Hopefully someday! I’ll definitely keep y’all posted!